goofball views on fandom and New Who are really entertaining just because he's so amazingly, shockingly, wrongheaded.
while Miles is approaching his hatred of Moffat-Who from entirely the wrong perspective and drinking from a big, steaming pot of jealousy juice,
Wrongheaded in what way? To me, Miles has it nailed spot-on. He's absolutly right about Moffat, just as he was absolutely right about RTD- and as he's absolutely right about Gatiss, Roberts, et al. And as for 'jealousy'- I don't think so. Miles is a legitimate commentator and critic of Moffat and more generally "modern tv". Moffat writes within the conventions of that which Miles loathes- and has been a cock to him in the past, so of course he's not going to get a decent write up.
If you haven't already, read Miles's 'About Time' series of critiques- you'll soon see that no one understands and contextualises Dr Who like he does. He's immensely pissed off that what was once a particular, unique, television programme is now generic throwaway trash. And that the same throwaway trash is lauded so highly by people who really should know better, just makes him furious. I can understand that, and he's totally correct.
What gets me is "fandom"s vicious, personal vendetta against Miles. He has emotional issues- which he has been very candid about. Fandom has leapt upon this like vultures on a warm corpse and made him the butt of every jibe going. Disgustingly, he is still routinely referred to as "Mad Larry" on the forums- and nothing is ever done about it. It's as if he's the only writer ever to suffer from such a problem. Mind you, this is the same fandom that turns on any critic who dares to criticise Dr Who in any form- as if any "negativity" is inherently bad and must be crushed, lest the show be cancelled again.
As the current tv version of Dr Who limps towards cancellation, the vitriol aimed at its critics just gets more shrill. Miles has all but ceased to have anything to do with it. And again, in that, he's to be much admired.
SBT